Exemption from Liability

Exemption from Liability

The principle of „Exemption from Liability“ stands out as a critical safeguard for individuals and entities reporting suspicious activities. This protective measure, embedded within the European Union’s 4th and 5th AMLD and further reinforced by German GwG, ensures that those who report in good faith are shielded from legal and professional repercussions.

The Essence of Exemption from Liability

The concept of „Exemption from Liability“ is primarily designed to encourage transparency and cooperation in the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing. By providing legal protection to reporting parties, these regulations aim to foster an environment where suspicious activities can be reported without fear of retaliation or legal consequences.

European Framework

The 4th AMLD laid the groundwork by stipulating that reporting entities and their employees or directors, who disclose information in good faith about suspected money laundering or terrorist financing, should not face liability. This protection applies even if the information reported turns out to be incorrect, provided there was no intentional misconduct or gross negligence.

Building on this foundation, the 5th AMLD introduced enhancements that further protect individual whistleblowers, ensuring they are not subject to adverse or discriminatory employment actions. This Directive emphasizes the importance of a secure and confidential reporting environment, granting individuals the right to file complaints with competent authorities if they face discrimination.

German Implementation

Germany’s GwG mirrors and expands upon the principles set forth in the AMLDs. It explicitly exempts individuals from liability when they report suspicions of money laundering or respond to information requests from the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU), as long as their actions do not stem from wilful intent or gross negligence. Furthermore, the GwG provides robust protections against employment discrimination for reporting employees, establishing a clear right to complain and ensuring access to legal recourse.

4th AMLD

Articles 37 and 38 of the 4th AMLD (Directive (EU) 2015/849) focus on „Exemption from Liability“ and protection for individuals reporting suspicions of money laundering or terrorist financing, respectively.

Exemption from Liability for Good Faith Disclosure

  • Good Faith Protection: This article provides legal protection for obliged entities and their employees or directors who disclose information in good faith in compliance with Articles 33 and 34, which relate to reporting suspicious transactions.
  • No Breach of Confidentiality: The disclosure made under these conditions is not considered a violation of any contractual, legislative, regulatory, or administrative confidentiality obligations.
  • Broad Liability Exemption: It ensures that neither the entity nor its staff will face any liability, even if they were unaware of the complete details of the suspected criminal activity or whether such activity was definitively illegal.
  • Encouragement of Reporting: By offering this exemption, the directive encourages the reporting of potential illegal activities without the fear of legal consequences, thereby aiding in the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing.

Protection of Whistleblowers

  • Protection Against Retaliation: This article mandates Member States to protect individuals who report suspicions of money laundering or terrorist financing—whether the report is made internally within the obliged entity or directly to the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU)—from retaliation, discrimination, or hostile treatment, especially in the context of their employment.
  • Scope of Protection: The protection covers employees and representatives of the obliged entity, ensuring they are safeguarded from threats, adverse employment actions, or any discriminatory treatment as a result of their reporting.
  • Support for Whistleblowing: By establishing these protections, the directive aims to create a safe environment for whistleblowers, further encouraging the reporting of suspicious activities and thus strengthening the overall AML/CFT framework.

5th AMLD

The 5th Anti-Money Laundering Directive (AMLD), specifically through the amendment of Article 38, significantly strengthens the protection framework for whistleblowers in the context of reporting suspicions of money laundering or terrorist financing.

Enhanced Protection for Whistleblowers

  • Broad Legal Protection: The revised Article 38 mandates that Member States must legally protect individuals, including employees and representatives of obliged entities, who report suspicions of money laundering or terrorist financing either internally within their organization or directly to the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU).
  • Protection from Retaliation: The protection is comprehensive, covering individuals from any form of threats, retaliatory or hostile actions, and specifically from adverse or discriminatory employment actions. This ensures that whistleblowers are shielded from any negative consequences that might arise from their reporting activities.
  • Right to Complaint: The amendment introduces a provision for individuals to present a complaint in a safe manner to competent authorities if they are subjected to threats, retaliation, hostile actions, or discriminatory employment practices due to their reporting. This adds an additional layer of security for whistleblowers, ensuring they have a formal avenue for redress.
  • Effective Remedy and Safeguarding Rights: It also guarantees the right to an effective remedy for such individuals to safeguard their rights. This means that whistleblowers have legal means to challenge and seek compensation or redress for any unjust treatment they might face as a result of their reporting activities.
  • Confidentiality Considerations: The article is careful to balance whistleblower protections with the confidentiality of the information gathered by the FIU. It implies that while whistleblower rights are protected, this should not compromise the confidentiality and integrity of the information related to money laundering or terrorist financing investigations.

German Bundestag Printed Matter 18/11555

The German Bundestag Printed Matter 18/11555 outlines a draft bill by the Federal Government for the implementation of the 4th AMLD, the execution of the EU Funds Transfer Regulation, and the reorganization of the Central Office for Financial Transaction Investigations. Focusing on the „Exemption from Liability“ aspect, here’s a summary and analysis of the relevant sections:

Exemption from Liability

  • Implementation of Article 37: Section 48 aligns with Article 37 of the Fourth Money Laundering Directive, ensuring that persons who report money laundering activities or respond to information requests from the Central Office for Financial Transaction Investigations are exempt from liability. This protection is conditional on the absence of wilful intent or gross negligence in the reporting.
  • Scope of Exemption: The exemption covers both direct reports of suspicious activities and responses to information requests by the Central Office, even in cases where no prior report was made by the obliged entity. The aim is to facilitate open communication and information sharing, crucial for effective money laundering investigations.
  • Protection for Truthful Reporting: Employees providing additional or initial information that is true, or not intentionally false, are protected from being held responsible. This encourages transparency and cooperation from individuals and entities in the financial sector.

Access to Information and Protection of Reporting Employees

  • Protection Against Discrimination: This section implements Article 38 of the Directive, specifically protecting employees who report money laundering activities from discrimination within their employment. This includes protection against unjustified dismissal, professional demotion, or hostilities, ensuring that whistleblowers and reporting employees do not face adverse consequences for their actions.
  • Access to Information: The regulation details how individuals affected by money laundering investigations have access to information, with specific provisions to safeguard the rights and safety of reporting employees. The Freedom of Information Act is limited in this context to maintain the confidentiality and integrity of financial investigations.

German Bundestag Printed Matter 19/13827

The „German Bundestag Printed Matter 19/13827“ details a draft bill by the Federal Government for the implementation of the Directive amending the Fourth EU Anti-Money Laundering Directive, with a focus on enhancing protections for employees who report suspicions of money laundering or terrorist financing. Specifically, Item 34 concerning § 49 addresses the „Access to Information and Protection of Reporting Employees“ and establishes a framework for the „Right to Complain“ about discriminatory practices faced by reporting employees. Here’s a summary and analysis of this section:

Right to Complain

  • Protection Against Discrimination: Employees who report suspicions of money laundering or terrorist financing, either directly under § 43 Paragraph 1 or internally to their obliged entity, and subsequently face discrimination in their employment, are granted specific protections. This includes any form of adverse action that contradicts the prohibition of discrimination stated in Paragraph 4.
  • Complaint Procedure: The provision allows for these individuals to file a complaint with the competent supervisory authority, as outlined in § 50. This implementation mirrors Article 1 Item 23 of the Amending Directive, ensuring that individuals who face retaliation or discrimination for their reporting actions have a formal avenue for redress.
  • Legal Recourse: Importantly, the ability to seek legal recourse remains unaffected by the complaint process. Reporting employees can still pursue litigation, particularly through labor courts, for any breach of their discrimination protections, regardless of whether they have engaged in the complaint procedure.
  • Confidentiality in Complaint Submission: To facilitate secure and confidential reporting, complainants are given access to a confidential information system managed by the supervisory authority. This system is detailed under § 53 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2, ensuring that complaints can be submitted discreetly and safely.

German GwG

The German Money Laundering Act (GwG) includes specific provisions aimed at protecting individuals who report suspicions of money laundering, ensuring they are exempt from liability and protected from discrimination in their employment. Here’s a summary and analysis of Sections 48 and 49 (4) and (5) focusing on these aspects:

Exemption from Liability

  • Protection for Reporters: Individuals who file a report under section 43 (1), related to suspicions of money laundering, or a criminal complaint under section 158 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, are protected from liability for making such a report or complaint. This protection is contingent upon the report or complaint not being filed with wilful intent or gross negligence.
  • Extended Protection: This exemption from liability also extends to employees who report internally to their superiors or designated in-house bodies responsible for handling such reports, as well as to obliged entities or their employees responding to information requests from the German Financial Intelligence Unit as outlined in section 30 (3), sentence 1.

Protection of Reporting Employees and Access to Information

  • Non-Discrimination in Employment: Employees of an obliged entity who report suspicions of money laundering internally or as per section 43 (1) are protected from any form of discrimination within their employment due to their reporting.
  • Right to Complaint: If an employee faces discrimination in their employment relationship contrary to the protection offered in subsection (4), they are entitled to lodge a complaint with the competent supervisory authority as per section 50. This provision ensures that employees have a formal avenue for redress without affecting their right to legal recourse.
  • Confidential Complaint System: The complainant has access to a confidential information system under section 53 (1) sentence 2 for submitting their complaint, safeguarding their privacy and the confidentiality of their report.

Sources: